From its very inception in the form of the first 1977 star wars film installment, there has been a definite rivalry between the star wars and star trek franchises, which rod roddenberry son of star trek. Star trek question again, i was struck not by the differences in laser strength or ship speed but by the different kinds of storytelling and world views each represents. And other galaxyshaking enigmas kindle edition by forbeck, matt. Many times, fans have an appreciation for both or a professed hatred for one.
First we must assume that each sides weaponry is effective against each other and capable of removing shielding. Find out which ship would come out on top in a oneonone space battle on todays episode of star trek vs star wars. Star trek vs star wars difference and comparison diffen. Star wars would win because its just so much more fun. Ever since princess leias starship hove into sight on the silver screen, fans of star wars and star trek. With this in mind it is a simple star trek victory. Apr 6, 2020 star wars vs star trek pictures and artwork. For over 40 years, star trek has been a fixture in science fiction television and film. In this episode we geeked out in the studio as me rachael. Aug 12, 20 first, star wars vs star trek normally means could the empire kick the federations ass. Because of the organizational elements of the federation, all of the federation planets pulling together to fight the empire with the help of the borg, romulans, etc, vs just the empire and a few bandits or rebels star trek has replicator technology that allows them to manufacture unlimited supplies, and transporter tech that allows them to beam troops anywhere instantly.
Feb 23, 2006 what would happen if the starship enterprise encountered the death star. But unlike those timeless questions this one really does seem to have a compelling. Star wars is set a long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away, although many characters are human, occasionally use earth metaphors and exhibit human character traits. Until the books of star wars tried to overcome the t. Star trek has transporters, photon torpedoes, and superior shield technology. Starships in startrek vs starships in starwars 58 results. Borg cube vs the death star star trek vs star wars. The general consensus is that star trek has more advanced weaponry, given the fact that they have shields whereas star wars. Like star trek, star wars is ultimately a hopeful story. Star wars vs star trek in five minutes star destroyer. Well, in the sake of universal peace among two very disparate yet similar. May 16, 2005 for the first time in 18 years, there will be no new star trek series on tv. There is the swashbuckling popcorn glory that stirs an imagination that is star wars. In a lot of ways, the star wars series defined what scifi is today.
If it was just ship vs ship, id say star trek ships win, not even close. First, star wars vs star trek normally means could the empire kick the federations ass. Star wars is a science fantasyfiction multimedia franchise created by george lucas. May 04, 2017 for decades fans of star wars and star trek have debated over which one is better. This entire debate is like meaningfully debating the combat prowess of unicorns vs. Also they can ftl in real space which is an added benefit. If we start talking about the whole of one versus the other then star trek wins without. Uss enterprised vs imperial ii star destroyer star trek. Who would win, the whole of star wars or the whole of star trek. Who would win in a space battle, star wars or star trek. A wormhole was discovered along the outter rim of the star wars galaxy sending them to the stargate milky way galaxy.
Even jj abrahms admits he modelled the new star trek on star wars. The united states military vs one imperial ii star destroyer star wars. Marks, long time scifi fan who reads far too many books and watches far too much tv. Give us your two cents on who would win in this crossuniverse match up. Marvel and star wars vs dc and star trek battles comic. Not only would star trek win but if gene roddenberry were brought back to life at any age, hed kick the shit out of george lucas at the same age. While were on the subject of star wars vs star trek, we might as well discuss the potential fighting strength of each franchises strongest warriors.
See more ideas about star trek, star wars and trek. Rebels vs starfleet star wars vs star trek who would win. Star wars vs star trek in five minutes stardestroyer. If its a question of taste ie do you like star wars more than star trek, debate becomes impossible because the answer is subjective. Rather than pitting all of star trek against battlestar galactica, or against. To the casual observer, star trek and star wars look a lot alike, beyond the obvious similarity between their names. Matt forbeck is an awardwinning and new york times.
Who ships are the best which naval force would win any given battle. Star wars is my favorite, without a doubt, but i definitely have a love for star trek as well. And other galaxyshaking enigmas by forbeck, matt isbn. If you were to ask a person what movie comes to mind when you say the word scifi, star wars would likely be the answer. The rise of skywalker will debut in less than a month, closing out this third trilogy of star wars films. Jul 10, 2015 star wars is my favorite, without a doubt, but i definitely have a love for star trek as well.
Star wars would not be able to win unless we use the eu and its 200 gigaton plasma shots every secoond. I am assuming that both star wars and star trek would each be able to destroy the others ships in a space battle. And other galaxyshaking enigmas forbeck, matt, bulloch jeremy, russ tim on. The problem of this topic is the concept of the borg. And on may 19, the star wars films will come to their own conclusion with the release of star wars. The first star wars movie, star wars episode iv, a new hope was released in 1977. This is as inane as superman vs goku star wars nerds will pull numbers out of their ass and technical manuals that are unrealistically high and trump all star trek numbers because. Firearm discussion and resources from ar15, ak47, handguns and more. Find out who would come out on top in this epic space battle on todays episode of star wars. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Now, side by side, they can line up aliens, technology, story points, weaponry, and heroes from the two great. And most important, in a fight between the empire and the federation, who would win. Random encouterusing all jedisith from all eras from the eu,films and the clone wars seriesusing q continuum from star trek. Im a doctor who fan, a star trek fan, and a star wars fan. Halo vs star wars vs star trek vs teletubies, which would.
The enterprise is more maneuverable, being able to do short warp jumps. Other crossover fanfiction archive with over 43 stories. Star trek federation vs star wars empire vs warhammer 40k imperil navy in a 3 way space battle. If you think about it, the borg should be borderline unbeatable in star trek, but since the plot line needs the federation to survive, they. I personally think the star trek expanded universe is much more interesting then the star wars. Star trek books, watch star trek, united federation of planets, tv star, film studies, star trek ships, lord, star wars. Funny memes that show star wars is better than star trek. Who would win out of the uss defiant from star trek and the millennium falcon from star wars find out here. I would be interested how people would compare the expanded universes of both star wars and star trek. Starships in startrek vs starships in starwars battles. May 18, 20 compare with any star trek title sequence and star wars will win every time when it comes to inspiring awe and setting the stage for the viewer to be taken away into a fantasy universe of. Star wars is more instinctive and more about feeling the moment, whereas star trek is too caught up with logic. The whod win star wars or star trek character got old very fast.
Star wars stargate in any occasion your using everything vs everything that means we have the deathstar. Dec 29, 2011 it seems the main factor in a fight between star wars and star trek will be speed of travel. But after reading it came down to star wars would get pwned and startreck vs new eden would be left. First, star wars vs star trek normally means could the empire kick the. Ever since princess leias starship hove into sight on the silver screen, fans of star wars and star trek have been debating these questions. Villains of star wars versus heroes of star trek, who would win. With hyperdrive and the ability to travel almost without any time loss between any points in space the star wars clan has the upper hand. Well, even with those, star trek could win because of their technology, the races in their universe and their ultimate planet killers. We compare the two and select a few of the best quotes the characters of these sagas left us.
Ships, well i think the star trek ships would win very easily in a firefight. With johnny bolton, ronan barbour, sophia thomas, melissa lugo. The general consensus is that star trek has more advanced weaponry, given the fact that they have shields whereas star wars ships do not. Oct 02, 2015 star trek depicts a world in which hard work, dedication, and cooperation can win the day. The two franchises are dominant in this setting of storytelling and have. Who would win, the whole of star wars or the whole of star. George lucas and jj abrams battle over the fate of star wars.
Star wars takes place in a galaxy far, far, away which is trapped in the iron grip of the emperor of the galactic empire, sheev palpatine. Because of the organizational elements of the federation, all of the federation planets pulling together to fight the empire with the help of the borg, romulans, etc, vs just the empire and a few bandits or rebels star trek. The use of hyperspace allowed the star wars universe to forego warp. May 28, 2004 first, star wars vs star trek normally means could the empire kick the federations ass. Even though we dont know how it ends, its safe to say that the good guys win.
Star wars vs star trek trailer battle for the galaxy fan. Even taking away pretty much omnipotent beings like q it would be a star trek win. Come in to read stories and fanfics that span multiple fandoms in the star wars and startrek. Star wars, originally a trilogy, is a space opera fantasy franchise set in the dis. Star wars is a world where a lucky few are born with magic bugs living in their cells that let them move. Sw books are supposedly quasicanon see the star wars encyclopedia foreword. The avengers and xmen team up with the jedi and sith and. If its a question of taste ie do you like star wars more than star trek. Star treks expanded universe is a glorious mess ars. By this time there are almost no star trek forces on the ground but just to be shure all star wars forces are pulled off the planet in question so the death star can enialate it. Before 2015, you could reasonably argue that star trek had gained the upper hand as a.
Daily mass in an effort to continue the practice of our faith in these trying times, we invite you to join us online for daily mass from bishop barrons chapel. But unlike those timeless questions this one really does seem to have a compelling answer. Star trek, originally a tv series, is a space western science fiction that centers around a crew who serves in starfleet, a spacebased peacekeeping and humanitarian armada. Star treks expanded universe is a glorious mess is it that much better than the star wars eu, or is it all about what we read growing up lee hutchinson jan 18, 2014 5. Chris pine in star trek beyond and daisy ridley in star wars. The galactic empire soon decides to launch an invasion into the stargate galaxy to conquer it. Incidentally, you dont even need all of star trek to defeat the star wars. A head to head battle with only federation ships would be interesting but unnecessary.
Star trek is a science fiction franchise created by gene roddenberry. There is the utopian ideals expressed in gene roddenberrys vision of star trek. Incidentally, you dont even need all of star trek to defeat the star wars empire. Uss enterprised vs imperial ii star destroyer star trek vs star wars.
Star trek, the original series first aired in september of 1969, featuring the now legendary and unforgettable, william shatner, as captain kirk. What series will come out on top in a battle of star trek vs. This is as inane as superman vs goku star wars nerds will pull numbers out of their ass and technical manuals that are unrealistically high and trump all star trek numbers because whoever made them up for the manual simply said so. So if we are to judge which is better in terms of social media popularity, star wars is the obvious choice. However, everyone thinks star wars is so high and mighty because they have the force and things that blow up planets.
The series opens with palpatines enforcer, the feared darth vader, boarding tantive iv, the personal starship of princess leia organa, the princess of alderaan. Jedisith star wars vs q continuumstar trek battles. Discover unique things to do, places to eat, and sights to see in the best destinations around the world with bring me. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading star wars vs. With plenty of opinions on either side the internet often turns into a battleground on this subject. Star destroyer death star star trek empire stars videos star. Oct 02, 2019 now dont misunderstand me, i love star wars just as much as star trek. Both scifi franchises successfully created rich universes which have inspired multitudes of books, video games, toys, and tv series. Who wins or loses isnt always the point, its the rich discussion as fans that makes comparing your favorite scifi shows a fun time. Star trek and star wars are american media franchises which present alternative scenarios of space adventure. The star wars facebook page currently has more than 19. Star wars shipmounted weaponry is far more powerful than anything flown in star trek barring perhaps borg assault. An army of redshirted ensignsfrom the first star trek vs.
1310 375 478 1399 1219 1334 737 980 1480 39 1046 1273 105 1177 563 9 1432 34 201 919 143 667 652 632 349 349 1104 749 730 1185 723 107 803 914 961 1195